Oscar statue © AP Photo/Amy Sancetta

Surprise! Oscar voters are mainly old white guys

20 Feb 2012 18:32:45 GMT

[MOST ANGRY COMMENTS] A look back at our first week.


Our headline was "Surprise! Oscar voters are mainly old white guys" and that immediately led readers to complain that we were being ageist. "Personally I can't believe MSN would allow this article to be written when it clearly is a slam against anyone who is an older white male." Point taken, movienut7 (and others) but here are the facts: "Nearly 94% of them are Caucasian, 77% are male and only 14% are younger than 50."

During Sunday night's Oscar broadcast, the words "I'd like to thank the Academy" will be uttered more times than anything other than "Shouldn't this be over by now?" But who are the people whose votes fill those wax-sealed envelopes? SPOILER ALERT: If you're an old white guy, you may already be a member.

According to exhaustive research by the Los Angeles Times, the 5,765 Academy voters are "markedly less diverse than the moviegoing public." Nearly 94% of them are Caucasian, 77% are male and only 14% are younger than 50. That might explain why "Mars Needs Moms" didn't get the Oscar nod it so obviously deserved.

Check out the msnNOW home page

Would a more diverse Academy lead to more deserving winners?

349Comments
Mar 5, 2012 9:38PM
avatar
Hey whoshivesaget, it's funny that the biggest affender is so rightougest. You judge everyone and hate everyone. What a joke. No one listen to what he says. He will stab you in the back and keep walking with no remorse.
Feb 24, 2012 12:31PM
avatar
Donetta. I have been discriminated against because of my color by all of my thug black students who treated me like crap because i happened to be an educated and kind white male. I have been discriminated against whenever I go into some fast food restaurant and the cashiers are all black particularly in the south. I have been discriminated against whenever my 92 years old white momma can't get help because she's not on welfare (even though living on 1400/mo.) If you're asking for the sea to part and give you all the help you need..being white is the wrong color in America today. Being a black female with lots of illigetimate children is "carte blanch" in America today. Tyler Perry is the ONLY mainstream black who is desperately trying to get Black america out of the gutter and into a kind of decency among all people. By the way, I stopped watching anything to do with the Oscars when Color Purple was snubbed. Just stop watching. Worry about the important stuff like when is Black America gonna stop settling for in your face crude low-minded violence. There are more whites desperately trying to raise the consciousness of Black America than Black  leaders. Go figure.
Feb 21, 2012 3:56PM
avatar
Frankly, the old guys are the ones I want to see --the ones with the starpower and charissma that has endured and proven not just a passing thing.  I sure wouldn't tune in for the likes of James Franco (wasn't that proven!). Tom Cruise or James Pattison.  If the moaning is about minorities rather than age--okay, Morgan freeman and Denzel Washington would be great to see, as well as Antonio Banderas and Don Cheadle.  They have great class.  But I sure wouldn't tune in to see Snoop Dog, Wesley Snipes the tax evader, Chris Brown the womanbeater or LLCool, Chris Rock, etc.  Bottom ine00just like affirmative action --they have to EARN it!
Feb 21, 2012 2:49PM
avatar
More breaking news: Reporters have discovered that the Image Awards which has been around for 43 years, is still mainly judged by old black people....stay tuned.
Feb 21, 2012 1:18PM
avatar
What?, old white men vote who gets an Oscar.  So What!, did not these same old white guys vote an Oscar for Denzel for Training Days?  That same year Russel Crowe gave a brilliant performance in "A Beautiful Mind" that in my  opinion far out shown Denzel''s. I enjoyed both movies but was this a politically correct award? if not, can anyone honestly compare the two performances and categorically state Denzel's was the superior performance.  Must have been a lot of pressure on the old white guys to vote that way or maybe they did just like Denzel's work better than Russels.  What jerks me off is how the press is presenting this, basically old white guys are evil, corrupt, and nasty.  Enough already with the liberal media take on anything not minority centered, environmentally friendly, socialist oriented behavior and dedicated to transferring all old white guys wealth to those that just don't have a clue nor the ability to amass their own.   Tired of it, fed up, and as someone who produced for society during my 65 years on this planet I will not make apologies for being "An OLD WHITE MAN".
Feb 21, 2012 12:28PM
avatar

In todays day and age when we are still being run by the "all powerful white man" says a lot about Hollywood.  I did not realize there was that much of a undeversified panel of voters. This is very sad yet it is one of those "figures" type of deal.  Thats probably why it took so long for Denzel to get an Oscar.  Now it seems like it was something they felt they better do or face a mutney.  Out with the old and in with the new is my vote!

Feb 21, 2012 12:22PM
avatar

What is so wrong with being an older white male?  This article is very racist.  What kind of reaction does MSN think they might get if  this article said older black males in the same context.  When did it become such a bad thing to be an older white male?  Personally I can't believe MSN would allow this article to be written when it clearly is a slam against anyone who is an older white male.  Shame on you MSN for publishing such a racist article.

Feb 21, 2012 12:10PM
avatar

Once again, if you have the unfortunate luck of being the combination of old, white, and male, you are trash and are only worthy of condemnation because once upon a time, people not at all related to you but who happened to share those traits did bad things to people.

 

Stereotypes: they're still around, just not for minorities anymore.

Feb 21, 2012 11:59AM
avatar
No, they would bend over backwards to avoid a racial issue, to the point they could possibly give it to a person of lessor talent.  Who really cares anyway?  Most of them are a bunch of scum.
Feb 21, 2012 11:58AM
avatar

Gawd { PUKE } Neoliberal attacks on 'the crime of being old and Caucasian" are nonstop. Sick

 

We built this nation, we run this nation, we engineered almost everything in existence.

If you don't like lower-case (implication: lower value people)  "old white guys" then never use a TV, electricity, airplanes nor just about anything else in the world.

 

CIAO HONEYS.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

popular this week

biggest movers

read more